Pete Hegseth, former Fox News host and Donald Trump’s nominee for U.S. Secretary of Defense, narrowly secured Senate confirmation late Friday night, despite a storm of allegations that cast doubt over his suitability for the role. The deciding vote was cast by Vice President JD Vance, marking only the second time in U.S. history a vice president has broken a tie to confirm a cabinet nominee.
The Senate was deadlocked at 50-50 after three Republican senators, including former majority leader Mitch McConnell, joined Democrats in opposing Hegseth’s nomination. McConnell issued a scathing critique of Hegseth, calling him “unprepared” to manage the Department of Defense, which oversees nearly three million employees and an $849 billion budget.
In his statement, McConnell described the role as “a daily test with staggering consequences for the security of the American people,” asserting that Hegseth had not demonstrated the capability to meet the challenges of the position.
Controversy Overshadows Confirmation Process
Hegseth’s confirmation process was marred by allegations of misconduct, including a 2017 sexual assault accusation, which he has denied, as well as claims of excessive drinking and infidelity during his two previous marriages. Earlier this week, fresh allegations of alcohol abuse and spousal misconduct emerged in a sworn affidavit from his former sister-in-law. Hegseth dismissed the claims, stating during his confirmation hearing, “I am not a perfect person, but redemption is real.”
The confirmation hearing also reignited debates over his controversial stance on women in combat roles. When questioned by female senators about past remarks suggesting women should not serve in combat, Hegseth clarified that his concerns were tied to maintaining military standards, not outright exclusion.
Mixed Support Among Republicans
While many Republicans rallied behind Hegseth, some key figures dissented. Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska cited his “lack of judgment” and “unbecoming behavior” as reasons for her opposition, while Maine Senator Susan Collins expressed concern over his limited experience for a role traditionally held by seasoned civil servants, generals, or politicians.
Hegseth, 44, is a veteran of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq but lacks the traditional qualifications for leading a national security agency. During his hearing, he summarized his priorities for the role: “Warfighting, lethality, meritocracy, standards, and readiness. That’s it. That is my job.”
Historic Tie-Breaking Vote
Vice President Vance’s vote to confirm Hegseth drew parallels to 2017, when then-Vice President Mike Pence cast the deciding vote to confirm Betsy DeVos as Secretary of Education. The move underscores the contentious nature of Hegseth’s appointment and the deep divisions in Washington over his leadership.
Despite the controversies, Hegseth will now oversee the Pentagon’s sprawling operations, including global military coordination and budget management. The confirmation grants Trump a major victory but leaves lingering questions about Hegseth’s ability to navigate the immense responsibilities of his position.